Answer by In Hoc Signo for Realistic version of White and black magic
IntentThe "what" of your magic system is the same, regardless of whether a particular spell is white or black magic. Something (such as heat, mass, or existence) is taken from one thing and applied to...
View ArticleAnswer by TheDemonLord for Realistic version of White and black magic
Easiest differentiation:White = Magic from yourself, with the consent of other or for the defense of Natural Rights:For example - you want to start a fire to make some food, you use some of your body...
View ArticleAnswer by o.m. for Realistic version of White and black magic
First, let me note that your example breaks the laws of physics, it does not just bend them. But that's why it is called magic.All effects will need some sort of energy. (Effects without energy are bad...
View ArticleAnswer by L.Dutch for Realistic version of White and black magic
While heat, wind and other physical phenomena are grounded in physics, and you can therefore use some physics to ground their magic in reality, the concept of black and white magic have to more to deal...
View ArticleRealistic version of White and black magic
So this is for my magic system since it's based on real world system. In my novel in the works named Successors magic works by bending the rules of science but not breaking them. Examples include Fire...
View ArticleAnswer by Laura for Realistic version of White and black magic
Chaos vs order: See the magic system in the Saga of Recluce by L. E. Modesitt.White mages are chaos mages. Black mages are order mages. White mages can throw fireballs, start a campfire, break rock,...
View ArticleAnswer by Stef for Realistic version of White and black magic
Foundational or subjective characterisation of magicYou have a decision to make.If you read many fantasy books which use the words "white magic" and "dark magic", and pay attention to how these...
View ArticleAnswer by ihaveideas for Realistic version of White and black magic
If you want to make your magic realistic, then the difference between black and white versions is permission, just like in real-world magic. White magic is whenever the target has granted permission...
View ArticleAnswer by dbmag9 for Realistic version of White and black magic
You've got science backwardsIn the real world, as you say, 'good' and 'bad' are subjective or at least confusing, and there are different opinions about the goodness or badness of different actions.But...
View ArticleAnswer by Thorne for Realistic version of White and black magic
White/Black ≠ Good/EvilWhite magic is magic that gives and black magic is magic that takes.White might be mostly found doing good and black doing bad but they can be used either way.Summoning a demon...
View ArticleAnswer by Atog for Realistic version of White and black magic
One Magic system that comes to mind is that of the HBO series Carnivale.The mythos is a little complicated, but it centers around the struggle of "good" vs "evil" avatars who will eventually cause the...
View ArticleAnswer by nigel222 for Realistic version of White and black magic
Black = WhiteThe difference is a moral judgement. Magic, just like science, is neutral. You choose how to use it. It just exists.(In certain places and times, medicine that actually saved lives was...
View Article
